5 Non-profit Organization Homepages That Make You Hold On To Your Money Instead of Donating

Explore common pitfalls to avoid in non-profit homepages to ensure your site captivates and motivates potential donors.

Table of Contents
    Add a header to begin generating the table of contents

    In the world of philanthropy, where every click could lead to a generous donation, the power of a well-crafted homepage cannot be underestimated. Yet, not all non-profits manage to hit the mark.

    While many organizations strive to create compelling online spaces that inspire visitors to open their hearts and wallets, others inadvertently achieve the opposite. It’s a delicate balance between invoking empathy and action, and missing the mark can mean the difference between support and skepticism.

    As we explore the digital doorsteps of various non-profits, we uncover five notable examples where, despite good intentions, their homepages might leave potential donors clutching their credit cards a little tighter, pondering if their contributions would truly make an impact.

    HAP

    To start with I want to be fair and mention that above the fold, they didn’t do too bad. It’s clean, it’s clear and I already get an idea of what this organization is about. However, immediately after I scroll down that’s when I start to question what this website is for.

    Where’s the info about who they support? What numbers have they to show for in terms of what they have done so far? Is this a Hmong support org or a health insurance sign-up homepage?

    This is why information selection is important. Don’t assume that everyone who visits your page is fully aware of who you are and what you do.

    Solid Ground

    For this homepage I won’t comment so much on the homepage design itself as I think it’s really not that bad. Where I feel it falls short on, is what content they are pushing as priority. Why is it more important about who the new director is?

    There’s good stories told in thumbnails and video titles, but this could have been pushed up higher in the content priority and visualized with easy to read text summaries as well as engaging visuals. Everything else they did quite okay.

    However, if they tried to follow how these non-profit homepages did their info placement, they could definitely be out of this list.

    Power Forward Utah

    Text after text after text after text. It’ll take me a good portion of my time to carefully read what this is all about. There’s a section on this homepage that has some sort of visualization and key details about the cause but even that wasn’t really clear to read with the overlapping content.

    Some good from their homepage are the numerously present donate buttons to encourage engagement. It’s just sad that some people might take one look at the numerous things they need to read and simply close the page thinking “Eh, maybe not today.”

    Understanding Us

    If at the end of scrolling a homepage you still don’t know what the organization does, then there’s some serious reconsideration that needs to be done. This is what I experienced for this page. Is it a Tai Chi program? Are they offering classes?

    It wasn’t until I clicked on their about us did I learn what they stood for. Above the fold they could have started with an image banner with text that says “We are a non-profit organization providing support to the homeless in Salt Lake City.”

    It’s ironic that the name is “Understanding Us” but I didn’t really understand their cause from going through their homepage.

    Coco’s Heart Dog Rescue

    Please don’t use your homepage’s welcome banner section, as an events billboard. If you’re focused on just making the website for internal use, then yes that’s fine. But if you’re trying to get more people who are new to your advocacy, to donate then don’t miss the opportunity to be creative and effective.

    Above the fold is one of the most crucial sections that can encourage a reader to scroll on or close the page. You want to have a message or an image that connects with the reader just as the homepage loads.

    If you are unsure what to put on your homepage, we have an Xtreme Homepage Makeover guide you can download for free.

    A Better Homepage for A Stronger Cause

    Our journey through these five non-profit homepages reveals a spectrum of missed opportunities and lessons in digital engagement. From the cluttered and confusing to the vaguely informative, each example underscores the critical need for clarity, compelling storytelling, and immediate engagement.

    As non-profits strive to capture the hearts and minds of potential donors, the key lies in presenting a clear, impactful message right from the first click. Let these examples be a call to action for non-profits everywhere: your homepage is not just a digital front door; it’s the beginning of a relationship with those who can help you make a difference.

    Crafting it with care, precision, and a deep understanding of your audience is not just beneficial—it’s essential for turning interest into action.

    Johnn Mendoza

    Johnn is a bird lover, freediver, and bookworm. He has been blogging since 2005 and enjoys learning about new technologies that helps society progress.

    Also from the Pros...

    How Is AI Decreasing Your Website Traffic?

    If your website traffic is slipping despite your best SEO efforts, you’re not alone. The rise of AI-powered search tools like ChatGPT and Google Gemini is reshaping the digital landscape, forcing businesses to rethink their strategies. Here’s why it’s happening and how you can adapt to stay ahead.
    Read More

    Never Skip On Audience Capture When Running Promos

    Search engine traffic isn’t as reliable as it used to be. With AI-driven search evolving and traffic trends changing, many businesses are feeling the impact. But here’s the truth: if you’re running promos without capturing your audience, you’re missing out on long-term growth. Here’s why audience capture is a game-changer and how it can future-proof your business. Let me know if you’d like further refinements!
    Read More
    1980s comic-style graphic depicting a man at a front desk handing a thank-you card to a customer

    Learn How to Thank Your Customers (and Get Feedback)

    When was the last time you said a genuine “thank you” to a customer? Not the polite end to a conversation but an intentional moment of appreciation that builds trust and opens the door to valuable feedback. A simple thank-you isn’t just good manners—it’s smart business. Here’s how showing gratitude can strengthen relationships, improve loyalty, and uncover insights to help your business grow.
    Read More
    80s comic depicting a broken car on the highway towards 2025

    5 Things You Need to Do for Your Website Before 2025

    The year is about to end and this is important for ANYONE who owns a website. The whole point of having a website is so you can take advantage of that massive customer pool online. You want a chunk off that digital marketplace.   With your business online, that means more sales right?Sad to say, it’s...
    Read More
    one click ai

    OneClick AI: This App Can Solve Business Problems in One Click!

    The buzz around AI is louder than ever, but for many small business owners, harnessing its power still feels like navigating a maze blindfolded. Enter OneClick AI, the game-changing platform designed to take the guesswork out of AI. Imagine solving your biggest business challenges with a single click — no technical expertise required, just results you can rely on. It’s AI made simple, secure, and tailored for businesses like yours.
    Read More
    An 80s-style comic scene in a vibrant office environment during regular hours. A man with a mix of curiosity and skepticism observes an androgynous robot extending a hand for a handshake. The robot represents ChatGPT, displaying an excited and helpful demeanor. The office setting includes retro desks, computers, and paperwork, capturing an atmosphere of curiosity and innovation.

    5 Things I Wish I Knew Before I Used ChatGPT

    When I first heard about ChatGPT, I was curious. Could an AI really handle creative work as well as a person? Could it even be better? I thought, if machines don’t make human errors, maybe ChatGPT could offer a flawless experience. I quickly learned that ChatGPT is a bit more nuanced. Here are five things...
    Read More
    devil representing ai leaning over an innocent guy's shoulder doing seo on a computer

    4 Ways AI Can RUIN your SEO

    As part of a web development team, we’re always hunting for the latest tech to up our game. Obviously, AI has made its way into our workflow, and honestly, it’s been a game-changer in a lot of ways. But let me tell you—if I wasn’t keeping a close eye on everything our automations were pumping...
    Read More

    5 Landscaping Company Homepage Designs That Make You Dream of Paradise!

    Discover how these 5 landscaping company homepages captivate visitors with easy navigation, and engaging content, inspiring more bookings.
    Read More